Mitt Romney: Putting Conservative Principles to Work in Health Care
By Jim Talent
Tuesday, August 21, 2007
Each candidate in the
2008 Presidential race will undoubtedly offer a health care plan. Those
plans will include initiatives ranging from a single payer system, to
employer mandates, to tax incentives for the purchase of private health
insurance. But only one candidate has actually done something, waded
into the issue and emerged with a successful plan that does not resort
to one-size-fits-all, government run "Hillary Care." That innovative
candidate is former Governor Mitt Romney. On April 12, 2006, Governor Romney signed into law landmark
legislation ensuring that every resident of Massachusetts would have
access to affordable, portable, quality private health insurance –
without higher taxes, an employer mandate or a government takeover of
health care. When Governor Romney decided to tackle the double-digit annual
increases in health insurance costs, the average uninsured resident in
Massachusetts had to pay $335 a month for private health insurance,
which did not include coverage for prescription drugs and featured a
$5,000 deductible. Moreover, the state was spending over $1.3 billion a
year on "free care" for the uninsured. Governor Romney actually got the Democrat-controlled
legislature to enact a plan that addressed these problems. He took the
time to understand what makes private health insurance markets work and
transformed the market in his state from one that was
government-controlled to one that allows competition to flourish. Governor Romney's health care plan featured a number of
reforms. First, his plan deregulated the overburdened Massachusetts
insurance market to reduce the cost of private insurance, while giving
consumers more choice from a broader range of plans. Second, the plan
addressed the problems caused by the fact that many people could not
get healthcare through their employers and could not afford it on the
individual market. Third, he redirected the millions of dollars that
were being spent on free emergency room care and used it instead to
help those who truly were not able to afford private health insurance. Finally, Governor Romney recognized that competition is the
key to the success of any market – so doing what no one had ever done
before, he created a new market where consumers can go to pick the
health care plan that suits them best. Called the "Connector," this
marketplace is not a new regulatory agency or insurance purchasing
pool. It is a place that gives people access to more choices, better
information, and lower costs in selecting a private health insurance
plan. The Connector also provides a way for individuals to purchase
insurance with the same pre-tax advantage given to those buying
insurance through their employers. Even better, the Connector gives
people the chance to buy private insurance independent of their jobs,
so that they don't have to worry about losing their coverage when they
change employers. But Governor Romney's reforms did not stop at reducing the
cost of insurance today. He also tackled a number of reforms that will
help reduce the rise in health care costs over the long-term. His plan
included medical transparency provisions that allow consumers to
compare the quality of hospitals and providers, while tracking and
recording the costs associated with the care they provide. The reforms
also instituted measures to encourage the use of electronic health
records, which will reduce medical errors and lower costs. What's been the result of all these reforms? Although the
reforms were signed into law just over a year ago, the changes are
dramatic. The same uninsured individual whose choice was formerly
limited to a policy with a $335 a month insurance premium with no drug
benefits and a $5,000 deductible now can purchase quality private
insurance, which includes coverage for prescription drugs, office and
emergency room visits, and a $2,000 deductible, for $175 per month.
Between July 1, 2006 and May 1, 2007, nearly 125,000 previously
uninsured residents of Massachusetts got health insurance coverage. Taxpayer-funded "free care" is falling at double-digit rates,
because the Romney reforms no longer allow people to let others pay for
their health care if they can afford their own health insurance. Those
who previously couldn't afford health insurance now have the help they
need to get access to affordable, quality, portable private coverage.
And, as he promised, Governor Romney did all this without raising taxes
and without a government take-over of health care. All of Governor Romney's reforms are consistent with the goal
of making private health insurance more available, flexible, and
affordable. That is why many conservative organizations have hailed
Governor Romney's health care reforms. The Heritage Foundation called
it "one of the most promising strategies out there." Massachusetts
Citizens For Limited Taxation said that Romney's plan was a responsible
solution to America's health care challenges. And the Ethan Allen
Institute praised Governor Romney's plan because of its focus on
personal responsibility and choice. The bipartisanship, innovation, conservative statesmanship and
creativity he exhibited confirms my view that he is the kind of leader
this nation needs.
Comments